Jimmy’s not Wakefield’s accomplice on Harper’s Island

Point
I knew my feeling about tunnels around the island from way back when would pay off. This isn’t the last we’ll see of them, either, as I believe this is how the accomplice was able to slip around the island whilst still having an alibi all this time. That is, if there is an accomplice.
I’m going on the record to say that I believe Jimmy as an accomplice to be a red herring. I had him pegged as the prime suspect long ago, but I really think we’re being taken for a ride. I guess it’s sort of like with finding out Wakefield is still around and doing at least most of the killings: if it is Jimmy helping him out, at this point it’ll be a bit of a let down.
Harper’s Island – Well that narrows things down a bit

Point
Well, I just knew that you don’t cast a Cylon and not use him. I guess I just wish I was wrong.
Lots of great theories have been flying around in the comments for the past couple of weeks, but tonight’s episode really seems to narrow down who is likely working with Wakefield in all of this. Seeing the majority of the main characters holed up in the Cannery during the shootings, there are only a few people to call out as possible accomplices at this point:
- Joel Booth — Yeah, we saw him shoot himself in the leg several episodes ago, but it was such an outrageously stupid act for a killing on this show that I’m almost willing to buy this theory. Sure, he was walking around in the woods, scared out of his wits when Malcolm happened upon him. Is he Wakefield’s son?
- Ben Wellington — This has been another theory being tossed around, and it goes hand-in-hand with the bag of money we’ve seen being handed around. We saw a body under the boat in the first episode, and we assume it’s Cousin Ben because of the cell phone going off under the water. Was it really Ben?


Most Commented (Past Week)