Keith

I’ve got a confession to make. I knew this episode was airing Thursday night in Canada, while we in the U.S. had to wait until Saturday night to wrap things up. So, I followed along with someone on Twitter while they basically live-tweeted what was going on. I know, I suck. Deb will say this later too.

So, I knew who the second killer was a couple of days ago, so I was able to watch this episode with different eyes. With that in mind, I’ve got a list of reasons why the reveal of the second killer was incredibly confusing and lame.

Read the rest of this entry »

Point

Let’s get right to the meat of the matter here. The killer is not Abby’s dad, despite what Madison has to say about who kidnapped her. First of all, did Madison ever see Abby’s father, or did she simply know her father was “the sheriff?” Could it be that the kidnapper was simply dressed as a sheriff or a police officer?

Secondly, it’s way too soon for a killer to be revealed. We won’t know until the third-to-last episode at the earliest — we’ve got more than that left to sit through.

Read the rest of this entry »

First let me start out by saying that there will be quite a few potential spoilers in this post. So, if you’re not interested in learning a bit about what might happen later in Harper’s Island, you may want to tread carefully.

I say that there are “potential” spoilers here because, as you will soon find out, this show’s changed quite a bit since the original screener came out sometime last year. Out of any screener I’ve seen in the past few years or so, I don’t believe I’ve seen as many major casting changes as there were with this show. So, with the cast changed so much, who knows what’s happened to the story, since it looks as though most of it had to be entirely re-shot!

Read the rest of this entry »